Abstract
This essay looks at how young people’s identity development is influenced by their online friendships. These online connections are becoming more essential for the development of one’s sense of self, socialization, and emotional support as these online communities make social interaction easier. I will look at the ways in which virtual friendships impact essential elements of identity, including belonging, values, and self-worth. By examining the patterns of digital communication, this essay draws attention to both the advantages and disadvantages, taking into consideration elements like peer validation, anonymity, and exposure to a range of viewpoints. I interviewed my closest friend, whom I met online via TikTok as well as incorporating my own personal perspective on this topic. I will compare the difference in experience between the two and provide insight into how young adults’ self-concept is influenced by their virtual surroundings.
Keywords: belonging, connection, community, friendship, social media, TikTok, Discord, identity development
The rise of online communities, and social media platforms in the past decade has significantly altered how individuals, particularly young adults, interact with one another. People now have access to formerly uncommon options to make friends, discover their identities, and interact socially across boundaries of space courtesy of these digital spaces. Standard notions of relationships and connections are changing because of the rise in technology, especially among young adults. I will conduct research on the numerous ways that technology influences young adults’ self-perception and the formation of their personal values. This study seeks to offer an informed overview of the intricate relationships between online connections and identity development in the digital era by comparing the advantages and disadvantages.
This paper will employ an interview style research approach. As a primary source, I interviewed my closest friend, “Y”. Y and I met through TikTok, a digital media platform. Much like other social media platforms, TikTok enables users to express themselves in a personalized manner. Through short-form videos that highlight hobbies, comedy, viewpoints or personal challenges, people may display specific aspects of who they are. In our case, Y and I first interacted through our TikTok videos that represented our common interest in reading. This commonality served as the basis for a friendship that went beyond simple online conversation and allowed for a sense of self to be developed with the both of us due to this authentic and genuine connection.
Personal Identity
Erikson (1968) defines personal identity as the extent to which a person has adopted clear and consistent goals, beliefs, and values. Marcia (1980) describes the formation of identity as a process that can involve different statuses of development based on the amount of exploration (experimentation with different values, beliefs, or goals, questioning and weighting different identity options) and commitment (personal interest in those values, beliefs, or goals, engaging in significant activities) that the adolescent experiences or has experienced. (“Social media: a digital social mirror for identity development during …”) While the above may be true, to me identify development means evolving and understanding your sense of self. It does not necessarily mean you change as a person; in fact, you gain a new insight into who you truly are, and you form a clear idea as to what you think represents who you are. In this new digital era, social media is a key player in identity development. As of recent, about 57% of all teens have made new friends online. According to the article by Vanesa Perez-Torres, “Recent studies have suggested that social media is a scenario of identity construction in which adolescents socialize. In digital spaces, adolescents can interact, display, and receive feedback about themselves, immediately contributing to the formation of their self-concept and exploration of their identity.” (“Social media: a digital social mirror for identity development during …”) (Cingel et al., 2022; Shankleman et al., 2021).
Interview
On the topic of social media, as new technology allows various opportunities for individuals to explore and express their interests, we have seen more and more young people connect and form relationships through social media. Katie Davis mentions, “Digital media have become central to the way adolescents experience their peer relationships. Friends use cell phones, social network sites, and instant messaging platforms to “hang out” with each other round-the-clock (Ito et al., 2009; Subrahmanyam & Smahel, 2011).” In the interview I conducted with Y, I asked the question “What was your initial experience with building friendships online?” She responded with, “I was a little hesitant but also intrigued as to where this would go.” Seeing as this is a relatively new means of forming connections, I related to her answer.
Forming an online friendship can be a bit tricky so I used the interview as a means to gather as much information as possible. “How do you establish trust with someone you’ve never met in real life?” I asked. Y responded with “Depends on their personality, but I am also someone who is naturally very trusting. I have the ability to have a good relationship with someone I met online better than someone I met in person because of the comfort behind the conversations and the chance to be vulnerable.” I then asked “Do you ever feel hesitant to share personal information with online friends on TikTok? Why or why not?” She replied, “I do, because it’s typically information that is very close to me and I don’t feel like it’s something I have to share.” The reasoning behind me choosing these questions in particular, was to tackle the preconceived notions that you can’t/shouldn’t develop trust with someone whom you’ve met online. Y’s answers gave me a new perspective and allowed me to recognize that despite the risks, sometimes in certain situations, you could allow yourself to be vulnerable and in turn, this could highlight itself as identity development.
Wanting to figure out how her online friendships showed themselves in identity development, I asked “Has your experience with online friendships on TikTok influenced your offline social life or relationships in any way?” Y replied “Yes it has. I am not as comfortable talking to my offline friends as much. Since meeting my online friends, I have developed a stronger and more defined sense of self.” To relate this back to my own experience, I have also found my online friendships to be a lot more fulfilling in comparison to my offline ones. Because you are communicating digitally, it opens the possibility to be vulnerable and share more of yourself.
Delving into the positive aspects of online friendships in regard to identity, exposure to diverse perspectives is among the most impactful. People from different social, cultural, and geographic locations can connect through social media, expanding their perspective and allowing for self-exploration. This self-exploration will typically lead to individual’s gaining a better understanding of their own values and allows for new reflections on identity.
Anonymity
Additionally, the slight anonymity of digital spaces also opens room for introspection. People have the chance to explore distinct aspects of their identites such as personal hobbies and interests. It gives the chance to be flexible and exercise your authenticity without the pressure of offline societal standards. Often, online friendships form around shared hobbies or interests, much like Y and me. This creates a sense of belonging and validation within our shared community.
Other positive effects include validation and emotional support. In the article by Patti M. Valkenburg and Jochen Peter they mention, “in comparison with face-to-face communication, online communication enhances the controllability of self-presentation and self-disclosure. This enhanced controllability, in turn, creates a sense of security in adolescents, allowing them to feel freer in their interpersonal interactions on the Internet than in face-to-face situations.” (“Online Communication Among Adolescents: An Integrated Model of Its …”) The anonymity of being online opens for the ability to be vulnerable with your thoughts and feelings in comparison with offline. Online friendships also help individuals become much more resilient emotionally. People gain emotional intelligence and exercise empathy which are important to creating a solid and positive identity. These interactions provide people with more self-assurance in their social skills, especially to those who find it rather difficult to communicate in person due to anxiety and overthinking. These interactions may aid heavily with emotional development in general.
Making Connections
Patti M. Valkenburg and Jochen Peter mention “online communication impairs adolescents’ quality of existing friends, because it displaces the time that could be spent in more meaningful interactions with offline friends [46], [47], [48]. Because online contacts are seen as superficially weak-tie relationships that lack feelings of affection and commitment, the Internet is believed to reduce the quality of existing friendships among adolescents.” (“Online Communication Among Adolescents: An Integrated Model of Its …”) Limited emotional depth is a huge concern when it comes to online friendships. Digital communication often lacks the complexity and depth of offline interactions such as body language, tone of voice and facial expressions, which makes it more difficult to fully comprehend and emotionally connect with others. This may sometimes lead to superficial connections that rarely offer emotional support, or the understanding required for more in-depth introspection and identity formation.
Individuals may often be tempted to highlight a version of themselves that is not quite consistent with who they really are because of the anonymity and adaptability of online spaces. Some may create idealized profiles that highlight only a particular facet of their persona to conceal weaknesses. This results in people developing a very distorted sense of self, which in turn keeps people from doing genuine self-reflection. This fabrication may eventually lead to uncertainty about an individual’s actual identity.
Online connections can provide companionship and support, but if they take the place of or weaken in-person interactions, they can also lead to social isolation. I framed this as a question for Y and I asked, “To what extent do you feel that the anonymity or distance of online spaces allows you to explore aspects of your identity that you might not in real life?” Y replied with “It is easier to talk to someone you meet at your current stage of life compared to in-person friends who knew me my whole life. With my new friendships, I found that they see me through struggles that may be hard to bring up offline and get to know me as my best self.” Although online friendships may sometimes weaken our offline connections, I would argue that unless you are over reliant on your online connections, it will not necessarily lead to social isolation. In fact, it can lead to you being more comfortable interacting in-person with others because you develop your communication skills and build your own self-identity.
Negative Aspects
Another negative aspect is that sometimes online friendships may not offer immediate emotional support compared to in- person friendships especially in times of crisis or significant personal development. Online friends may not always be available the emotional support or guidance that can be crucial at the moment. Text-based contact may also lack the closeness and immediacy of in-person friendships. However, according to this article from the Pew Research Center, “Social media not only connects teens to information and friends, but also connects them to opportunities for social support from their friends, peers and broader social networks. Among teens, 68% have received support on social media during challenges or tough times.” (“Chapter 4: Social Media and Friendships – Pew Research Center”) From my own personal experience, I have also found that social media is very fulfilling when it comes to helping and supporting others through their challenges as well as tough times they may be going through. In regard to the immediacy of it, although it may not always be immediate, I would argue that you receive a lot more emotional support in comparison to offline friendships because of the authenticity behind your connections.
Like many young individuals in this new digital age, I chose to build a platform on the social media app TikTok during the height of the Covid quarantine, where I shared my love of reading with the book Tok community. I ultimately established an online connection with Y by creating that account. We share many commonalties from things such as music and reading to culture and beliefs. As I mentioned above in my research paper, our friendship had a significant impact on my personal identity. I refined my sense of self and was able to express vulnerability that I may not have expressed in my offline friendships. Through this, I received positive affirmation in which solidified aspects of my personal identity. I solidified parts of my personal identity through positive affirmation. My experience with online friendships allowed the opportunity for identity development, emotional maturity, and self-discovery. With digital media platforms, people may experiment with various aspects of their identity, gain a deeper understanding of themselves, and eventually strengthen their sense of self by interacting with others in a diverse and adaptable setting.
Conclusion
In conclusion, online friendships can significantly contribute to the formation of an individual’s identity by providing chances for introspection, camaraderie, and emotional development. Through these connections, people have the opportunity to experiment with various components of their identities, be exposed to various viewpoints, and get support and validation from others who share their values. There certainly are drawbacks to these digital friendships as well. The possibility of deception and weak connections being prime examples. My own experiences have shown me that although online friendships may offer clarity and a feeling of community, they must be handled with authenticity and genuineness. Integrating online and offline connections and maintaining these friendships that support self-expression and personal development are essential to the formation of a powerful sense of self. Online connections can ultimately help us understand who we are if approached with mindfulness.
References: Davis, K. (2011). “A Life in Bits and Bytes: A Portrait of a College Student and Her Life with Digital Media.” (“A life in bits and bytes: A portr... preview & related info | Mendeley”) Teachers College Record (1970), 113(9), 1960–1982. https://doi.org/10.1177/016146811111300903Links to an external site. Davis, K. (2012). Friendship 2.0: Adolescents’ experiences of belonging and self-disclosure online. Journal of Adolescence (London, England.), 35(6), 1527–1536. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adolescence.2012.02.013 Lenhart, A. (2015, August 6). Chapter 4: Social media and friendships. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2015/08/06/chapter-4-social-media-and-friendships/ Pérez-Torres, V. (2024, April 24). Social media: A Digital Social Mirror for identity development during adolescence - current psychology. (“Social media: a digital social mirror for identity ... - Springer”) SpringerLink. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12144-024-05980-z#:~:text=Onsocialmediatheaudience,andtheneedforacceptance)Links to an external site.. Valkenburg, P. M., & Peter, J. (2011). “Online Communication Among Adolescents: An Integrated Model of Its Attraction, Opportunities, and Risks.” (“Online Communication Among Adolescents: An Integrated Model of Its ...”) Journal of Adolescent Health, 48(2), 121–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2010.08.020


Share Feedback
Feedback is nice