Abstract:

In February 2024, adults in the United States aged between 18 and 24, spent 186 minutes per day engaging with social media platforms. In comparison, respondents aged 65 and older dedicated approximately 102 minutes of their day to social media. Tik Tok was the most engaging social media platform for U.S. consumers aged between 18 and 24 years (Statista, 2024) On average, people spend about 143 minutes (that’s 2 hours and 23 minutes) on social media every day. That’s almost 2.5 hours per day spent scrolling through different platforms. Teenagers are the biggest users, especially teenage girls, who spend nearly 3 hours a day on social media. (Soax, 2024) This is a staggering amount of time to be investing into doing the same activity repeatedly, and as we know, repeating a behavior causes conditioning and solidification of both how we perform the behavior and what effect it has on us. As Bailey Parnell said in her Ted Talk on social media & mental health, “Anything we do this often is worthy of critical observation. Anything we spend this much time doing has lasting effects on us.” (Parnell, 2017) Over time, social media has become increasingly more dangerous and toxic for people to be a part of, with the rise of photoshop, facetune, and expectations of what your social media page “should” look like, or more importantly, what you should look like. In this essay I will use textual analysis, interviews, and observation of social media platforms to dive into the general toxicity of social media, the facade people portray themselves with on their social media platforms, the toxic comparisons that take place when viewing other people’s “highlight reels” (especially in the youth), and the negative, detrimental effects that come from social media usage- particularly in developmental years.

Introduction:

            Social media consumption/usage is being studied under both a broad and narrow scope, with effects being seen in contexts as wide as active vs. passive social media use, and contexts as specific as unrealistic beauty standards being set with the use of facetune and photoshop. As social media has become more popularized and used, the starting age of social media use has dropped drastically, with young children spending many hours a day consuming social media content and growing up with it as a regular part of their life and routine. While social media can be a good resource for information and connection, it has been infiltrated with much toxicity and danger than is leaving long lasting effects on the youth who are using it consistently from a young age. If negative effects are being seen in adults who use social media, it is certainly worth exploring what these negative effects look like to the vulnerable, undeveloped brain of an adolescent who may not be able to see as clearly through the façade of social media content.

Self-oriented vs. other-oriented use:

            Steinsbekk et al. conducted a study where they interviewed children at ages 10, 12, and 14 to examine psychosocial development and mental health over time in relation to their social media usage, and they split the data into self-oriented use and other-oriented use. They explained these different data points as, “…self-oriented use consists of original posts, updates, and photos, whereas other-oriented use comprises merely liking or commenting on others’ posts and pictures.” (Steinsbekk et al., 2020) The separation of types of use helped conclude that self-oriented use may boost appearance self-esteem and those with increased other-oriented use may be more likely to engage in social comparisons, negatively impacting self-esteem, but while self-oriented use as a standalone may boost appearance self-esteem, those with a lower starter level of appearance self-esteem may also refrain from self-oriented use out of fear or shame. The study found that, “Participants with more frequent other-oriented social media use at ages 10 and 12 than others, reported lower levels of appearance self-esteem than others two years later. The impact of other-oriented social media use on appearance self-esteem was higher than the impact of self-oriented social media use.” (Steinsbekk et al., 2020) This sets the stage for our understanding that social media is a complicated forum with unwritten rules and that harm can even be found in places that can’t be distinctly seen or recognized.

The curated online persona:

If you downloaded social media at a young age, particularly Instagram, you most likely- unbeknownst to you at the time- posted some pretty unflattering or embarrassing selfies, “cringey” memes or other posts that ultimately got deleted as time went on because you became self-conscious about them, but at the time you posted them- that was what you truly wanted to post, likely despite what others think. But as we get older, we become more immersed in the sometimes spoken, but let’s face it, most of the time, unspoken culture of what is and isn’t acceptable to post on our pages along with and endless list of other possible influences, and we begin to create a carefully curated highlight reel of what we believe to be our most flattering pictures and most exciting moments.

Jacobson talks about the many different dangers of having a curated online persona in her article Social Media and Self-Doubt– saying, “For kids experiencing anxiety or depression, carefully edited social media posts can act as a smoke screen, masking serious issues behind pretend perfection and making it harder for parents or friends to see that they need help.”, “Another, more prevalent problem, says Dr. Emanuele, is that for some teens their social feeds can become fuel for negative feelings they have about themselves. Kids struggling with self-doubt read into their friends’ images what they feel they are lacking.” And “’I knew a girl who had an eating disorder. We all knew it. It got so bad that she ended up going to a treatment center, but when she put pictures up of herself on the beach looking super-thin everyone liked them anyway,” says Sasha. Logically, she says, she knew the pictures weren’t current and the girl was very ill, but that didn’t stop her from feeling a twinge of jealousy. “I remember thinking ‘I wish I looked like that’ and then being horrified at myself.’” (Jacobson, 2024) For context, Sasha is a 16-year-old high school student.

Even though Sasha knew the girl was struggling with an eating disorder and even felt horrified with herself after having the thought, she still felt a level of jealousy towards what her very sick body looked like, wishing hers could look the same. This just goes to show how silent the dangers of a curated persona can be- Sasha’s thought was subconscious, and although fleeting, the situation could look very different and in many other cases, it does. The curated online persona not only hurts the person curating it by giving them a false sense of self over time, but also the people consuming the false content, as it creates unrealistic standards for appearance or lifestyle that can later have negative effects on self-perception.

Photoshop, Facetune and other editing:

Photo editing software completely changed the social media game, allowing anybody to alter their photos as much as they want and appear as whoever they want in their online personas.  “According to a survey of the Renfrew Center Foundation [4], 50% of SNS users edit their photos before posting them to Social Network Sites (SNSs).” (Ozimek et al., 2023) While it isn’t inherently wrong or against any rules to alter your appearance or general persona online, doing so repeatedly over time creates a divide between who you are in person vs. your ideal, curated version online & in turn has an array of effects on mental health and perception both of self and those around us. “Numerous studies indicate a negative association between photo editing behavior on SNSs and body satisfaction. Furthermore, users who retouched their pictures reported feeling less attractive, poorer self-esteem, and increased negative mood. Photo editing behavior may also encourage individuals to view their body as an object, reinforcing associated risks such as body shame, depression, and eating disorders.” (Ozimek et al., 2023) This is where the divide of self-oriented use and other-oriented use becomes so important to take into account when analyzing social media usage, because while it was found that self-oriented use can boost self-esteem, this can be challenged when other factors are put into play. In this case, the other factor is the unrealistic beauty standards being engrained into social media with the rise of photoshop, facetune, and other editing methods, especially because this editing is undisclosed more often than not. “I’ve always edited my photos because snapchat and Instagram filters were so accessible and made me look so much better, but in reality I didn’t look like that, and now that I look back at those photos I don’t even really recognize myself… There was a point in which social media standards were so crazy for me, I found myself photoshopping my body even at my very lightest weight to the point that my body didn’t even look real anymore.” (R. Bautista, personal communication, November 10, 2024.)

Subconscious perception:

While we recognize that we put our best selves forward on our social media accounts to create our own carefully curated highlight reel- may this be in the form of editing photos, deleting photos that “don’t get enough likes” or are outdated and cringey, or just carefully choosing what photos to post based on what we want others to think, we don’t always consciously recognize that the content we consume is also just pieces of other people’s highlight reels. “Adolescents are prone to social comparison, which plays an important role in identity development.” (Weinstein, 2017). Young, undeveloped minds are spending increasingly more time consuming false, edited content that is being subconsciously perceived as normal and adopted as so, which ends up dictating the content they post (or don’t post) and the way they view themselves and others.

As somebody who experienced their developmental years while using social media, especially as a teenage girl,“Appearance self-esteem seems to be more important to adolescent girls’ than to boys’ global self-esteem (Wichstrom & von Soest, 2016), and prior work suggests that girls internalize media-promoted body ideals (e.g., thin-ideals) to a greater extent than boys.” (Steinsbekk et al., 2020), I have experienced first-hand the toxicities of using social media and the effects it carries. I didn’t realize how much social media was affecting me until it had already been affecting me for years and rooted itself into my self-perception. When I was in middle/high school I always felt an immense amount of insecurity about myself from content I consumed and social pressure to look a certain way or post a certain way on mysocial media pages. R. Bautista shared a similar experience during our interview where she said, “I got fed into the constant loop of online validation, fake surface level comments and it altered my perception of self because I thought I was worth my weight in social media likes and comments.” (Personal communication, November 10, 2024.)

Comparison is the thief of joy:

When we spend our time consuming other peoples’ content and comparing our lives to theirs in a negative manner, we effectively diminish the good in our lives and start to have a skewed perception on what our lives are “supposed” to look like, despite knowing everybody is so drastically different. “In high school I felt really jealous because other people’s parents were a lot more lenient than mine, and they would all post together hanging out and I felt like my high school experiences weren’t as good or as cool as theirs because I couldn’t be out with them. I feel like this took away a lot from the joy I DID have in my life, because I spent all my time wishing I could be out doing what they were doing instead of appreciating the good things I had in my life at the time.” (R. Bautista, personal communication, November 10, 2024.)

In Emily Weinstein’s article, she explains, “…individuals who browse positive-only Instagram feeds are more likely to have worse emotional states post-browsing than those who a) are primed to consider the correspondence bias while browsing and/or b) browse more balanced versions of the Instagram feeds, which provide available counter-examples to the perception of others’ lives as only positive.” (Weinstein, 2017). This shows that those exposed to content from people they perceive as superior or better off are negatively affected emotionally just by browsing through said content, and it also serves as a good example of why there is added danger for adolescents using social media, as they may not be primed to understand the reality of the content they consume.

Conclusion:

During our interview when asked which side negatively affected her the most over time between self-oriented use and other-oriented use, R. Bautista said she couldn’t decide, saying, “You’re perceiving people while you’re being perceived, it goes hand in hand.” (Personal communication, November 10, 2024.) Finding the root of negative effects of self-perception during developmental years is incredibly difficult because there are so many factors that come from so many different places that can play hand in hand together to create a bigger effect. But one thing that can be recognized confidently is that social media does have negative effects on those who use it during developmental years, to what degree is still yet to be found. 

References

Jacobson, R. (2024). Social media and self-doubt: How parents can help kids resist the pressure created by artfully curated social media feeds. Child Mind Institute. https://childmind.org/article/social-media-and-self-doubt/

Ozimek, P., Lainas, S., Bierhoff, HW. et al. (2023). How photo editing in social media shapes self-perceived attractiveness and self-esteem via self-objectification and physical appearance comparisons. BMC Psychology, Volume 11. Article 99. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-023-01143-0

Parnell. (2019). Is Social Media Hurting your Mental Health? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Czg_9C7gw0o

Soax. (2024). Time spent on social media. https://soax.com/research/time-spent-on-social-media

Statista. (2024). Time spent on social media in the United States by age in February 2024.https://www.statista.com/statistics/1484565/time-spent-social-media-us-by-age/#:~:text=In%20February%202024%2C%20adults%20in,45%20minutes%20daily%20on%20Facebook

Steinsbekk, S., Wichstrøm, L., Stenseng, F., Nesi, J., Wold Hygen, B., & Skalická, V. (2021). The impact of social media use on appearance self-esteem from childhood to adolescence: A 3-wave community study. Computers in Human Behavior, Volume 114. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2020.106528

Weinstein, E. (2017). Adolescents’ differential responses to social media browsing: Exploring causes and consequences for intervention. Computers in Human Behavior, Volume 76. Pages 396-405. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2017.07.038